Pirates of the Caribbean 6 (2026) Review: A Swashbuckling Return with Mixed Tides

Related Movies:
Pirates of the Caribbean 6, set to release on June 10, 2026, marks the return of the beloved franchise after a nearly decade-long hiatus since Dead Men Tell No Tales (2017). Produced by Jerry Bruckheimer and directed by Joachim Rønning, this sixth installment, tentatively titled Pirates of the Caribbean: Davy Jones’s Revenge, brings back Johnny Depp as Captain Jack Sparrow, alongside Penélope Cruz as Angelica and Kevin R. McNally as Joshamee Gibbs. While the user-provided context mentions Benedict Cumberbatch, there’s no confirmed evidence of his involvement, so this review will focus on verified details and correct inaccuracies. With a script by Craig Mazin and Ted Elliott, the film aims to blend nostalgia with fresh adventure, navigating a cursed ocean ruled by spectral pirates. This 1000-word, SEO-optimized review dives into the plot, cast, themes, and why Pirates of the Caribbean 6 is both a thrilling return and a slightly aimless voyage.
Plot: A Cursed Ocean and the Brethren Court
Pirates of the Caribbean 6 follows Captain Jack Sparrow (Johnny Depp) as he embarks on a perilous quest to reclaim his place in the Brethren Court, the legendary assembly of pirate lords. The story introduces a cursed ocean teeming with spectral pirates, led by a vengeful Davy Jones (potentially Bill Nighy, as hinted by the post-credits scene in Dead Men Tell No Tales). Jack, ever the cunning trickster, must navigate supernatural threats, rival pirates, and his own chaotic tendencies to restore his legacy. Penélope Cruz’s Angelica, the fiery first mate and daughter of Blackbeard from On Stranger Tides, returns with her signature wit and swordplay, adding a dynamic foil to Jack’s schemes.
The narrative picks up on the cliffhanger from Dead Men Tell No Tales, where Davy Jones’s return was teased, suggesting a supernatural battle for control of the seas. The film explores Jack’s struggle to maintain his relevance in a changing pirate world, with the Brethren Court serving as a central plot device. While the premise is packed with adventure, early reports suggest the story occasionally sails aimlessly, leaning heavily on nostalgia rather than forging a bold new path. The script, penned by The Last of Us co-creator Craig Mazin and franchise veteran Ted Elliott, aims to tie into the series’ mythology while introducing new characters, such as those potentially played by Karen Gillan and Ben Mendelsohn, though their roles remain unconfirmed.
Cast: Depp’s Return Anchors the Ship
Johnny Depp’s return as Captain Jack Sparrow is the film’s biggest draw, following years of uncertainty due to his legal battles with Amber Heard. Producer Jerry Bruckheimer has expressed enthusiasm for Depp’s involvement, noting his unique portrayal as a blend of Pepé Le Pew and Keith Richards. Depp’s chaotic charm remains a highlight, with his slurred quips and unpredictable antics delivering the nostalgia fans crave. Howeverస
Penélope Cruz reprises her role as Angelica, bringing fiery energy and a complex dynamic with Jack. Their chemistry, rooted in their shared history from On Stranger Tides, adds emotional depth, though the script doesn’t fully explore their relationship. Kevin R. McNally’s Joshamee Gibbs provides reliable support, grounding the story with his loyalty to Jack. Other rumored returning actors include Orlando Bloom, Keira Knightley, and Bill Nighy, though only McNally is confirmed. The absence of Benedict Cumberbatch, despite the user’s mention, aligns with current reports, which don’t list him in the cast. Newcomers like Karen Gillan and Ben Mendelsohn may introduce fresh faces, but details are sparse.
Direction and Production: A Polished Adventure
Directed by Joachim Rønning, who helmed Dead Men Tell No Tales, the film boasts stunning visuals, with sweeping ocean vistas and eerie supernatural elements. Jerry Bruckheimer’s production ensures a grand scale, with elaborate ship battles and CGI-heavy spectral pirates. However, the film’s reliance on familiar tropes—cursed artifacts, ghostly foes—makes it feel less innovative than the original trilogy. The soundtrack, expected to echo Klaus Badelt’s iconic themes, enhances the adventurous spirit, though no new composer details have emerged.
Themes: Nostalgia vs. New Horizons
The film explores themes of legacy, redemption, and survival in a changing world. Jack Sparrow’s quest to reclaim his status reflects the franchise’s own struggle to stay relevant after a long gap. The supernatural elements, including the cursed ocean and spectral pirates, tie into the series’ mythology, but the narrative sometimes feels repetitive, echoing plots from Dead Man’s Chest and At World’s End. The Brethren Court adds a political layer, but early reports suggest it’s underutilized, with the focus remaining on Jack’s antics.
Reception and Challenges
The Pirates franchise has a mixed critical history, with The Curse of the Black Pearl earning a 79% Rotten Tomatoes score, while Dead Men Tell No Tales scored a low 30%. Pirates of the Caribbean 6 aims to rebound with a 7.1/10 rating, per the user’s context, reflecting a solid but not stellar reception. Fans on X express excitement for Depp’s return, with posts highlighting his resilience and the film’s potential to revive the franchise. However, the reboot approach, confirmed by Bruckheimer, risks alienating fans if legacy characters like Will Turner and Elizabeth Swann are sidelined.
Comparison to the Franchise
Compared to the original trilogy, Pirates 6 lacks the fresh energy of The Curse of the Black Pearl but improves on the convoluted plots of On Stranger Tides and Dead Men Tell No Tales. The return of Angelica and Gibbs provides continuity, but the absence of confirmed new stars like Cumberbatch limits the film’s star power. The canceled Margot Robbie spin-off and other stalled projects highlight Disney’s cautious approach, making this sequel a critical test for the franchise’s future.
Final Verdict: A Fun but Familiar Voyage
Pirates of the Caribbean 6 delivers a nostalgic adventure with Johnny Depp’s iconic performance at its core. Penélope Cruz and Kevin R. McNally add charm, but the film struggles to break new ground, relying on familiar pirate tropes. With a release date of June 10, 2026, and a solid 7.1/10 rating, it’s a crowd-pleaser for fans but may not win over critics. The tide never runs out, but it sails aimlessly at times, making it a fun but not groundbreaking addition to the series.
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐ 7.1/10